Hi everyone,
We had two protests on the trade between Fantasy Wrecker and Tragic Magic:
Wrecker received - Ayomanor and Horton
Vs.
Tragic received - Kincaid/Spears/TeSlaa/Restrepo
Generally speaking, the FFPC rarely overturns trades. We use trade calculators from sites like DynastyTradeCalculator.com or DynastyLeagueFootball.com. We will sometimes use a 2 to 1 ratio to determine the value disparity and we might use this in our decision on any protested trades.
We emailed both owners to confirm the trade and make sure there were no left out players or picks. Both owners emailed us back and confirmed this was the correct trade with no missing pieces.
While using both trade calculators, here is what we got:
DTC - Kincaid side - 13.4 Vs. Horton side - 2.0 --- 6.7:1
DLF - Kincaid side - 234.2 Vs. Horton side - 12.6 --- 18.5:1
As you can see we are far above 2X the value on both calculators.
While the owner of Fantasy Wrecker did give us a detailed explanation as to why he did this trade and we did consider his response on our ruling, both WRs he received did not have high draft capital and it is tough to let a trade stand with two players that have proven nothing in the NFL. Kincaid did have a down 2024 season, but was a monster in 2023 and is in a top 5 offense in the league. Spears is the 1B on the Titans, but did come along towards the end of the 2024 season and should see his role expand. Both Kincaid and Spears are proven NFL talent.
FFPC rarely reverses trades. However, we are reversing this trade based on valuation.